What is Innovation?

Evolution of lighting

This question comes up a lot, whether directly or in the context of another question and usually because the answer is complex. It’s not just about dictionary definitions, or fancy graphical models and frameworks; it’s also about mindset, a way of thinking and viewing the world, and often about the innovator as an individual.  This article wont delve into the psychology of an innovator, but will try to simplify a very complex field for one specific purpose: To create some clarity and offer some structured knowledge to help start some constructive dialogue when the word innovation crops up.

Innovation.

The term is most often used as shorthand for ‘new’ or ‘different’ and all too often dropped into objectives and organisational goals like some sort of word-candy, without real thought about what it means, how it might be measured, or just how true innovation could impact on the status quo.
Unfortunately there isn’t a single agreed upon definition, but there are plenty suggestions out there to choose from.

Here are some favourites to think about:

  • “Something different that has impact” – Source

  • “Successful step change” – Source

  • “Fresh thinking that creates value” – Source

  • “It is the means by which the entrepreneur either creates new wealth-producing resources or endows existing resources with enhanced potential for creating wealth” – Source

  • “The systematic application of [new] knowledge to [new] resources to produce [new] goods or [new] services.   (At least one ‘new’ needs to be present)” – Source

The list could go on a lot longer, but rather than deluge you with a torrent of definitions, there are general themes that are consistent.

Innovation:

  • involves something new or original (this separates innovation from continuous improvement)  and

  • creates potential value (requiring there to be some advantage to the innovation itself)

The second theme is interesting because in most definitions it acts as a constraint, in many cases requiring commercial success.  

Experience has made it clear to us that setting out with a goal of commercial success is a truly dreadful starting point for just about every possible goal.  In addition to limiting your mindset by the current perceptions of value, starting with commercial considerations closes your mind from fully exploring possibilities.  A problem that someone else feels is worth solving, will always be the better place to start.

Originality, and ‘newness’, are necessary to capture the essence of innovation, but the concept of success is much more nebulous and problematic. 

“Successful” innovation?

This term always reminds me of a debate I was fortunate enough to have with an eminent professional and author in the field of innovation.  Our debate was over the status of Tesla Inc. as a successful innovator.  He held the view that commercial success is a defining factor of innovation, and Tesla has not achieved the profitability necessary to be considered a successful innovator.  Yet. 

I feel this shows the problem with success based definitions – Success is rooted in context, a matter of perspective, and is not always commercial.  To explain:  Tesla has a clearly stated mission: “to accelerate the transition to sustainable transport”, and against this mission they have not only been successful, but they have managed to achieve this on funds raised from speculative investors.  Having open-sourced their patent portfolio their contribution to the industry is now fixed, the R&D costs of catching up are avoidable for everyone else. In my view, this is a pretty impressive innovation in commercial management against a non-commercial goal.  Reality will require Tesla to become profitable, but to regard them as unsuccessful innovators feels like holding to a definition in a case that proves it inadequate.

An innovation can deliver on an ‘unimportant‘ need and fail commercially, but equally the fact that I don’t want a selfie stick or a fidget spinner, doesn’t mean other people won’t buy them.  (Ed – We’re using ‘unimportant’ to describe innovations which solve problems in a way that just doesn’t create enough value for consumers. Google for “Chindōgu” and you’ll find some wonderful examples like the baby mop)

Innovation then needs the creation of value for your audience.  If your product or service offers greater overall value than alternatives, commercial success can be achieved.  Clearly there are going to be many situational factors that affect success and these need to be acknowledged throughout the process of innovating as well as the process of commercialising your innovation. 

So now we’ve explored this some, which definition do I advocate? 

Well of course I created my own:

“Innovation is the application of knowledge in new ways, to create differentiated goods or services that deliver meaningful value to a defined audience.”

Having said all of this, definition is all well and good for us individuals, concerned with the act of innovating but when given a brief to innovate, it’s not necessarily enough. 

Time to explore what innovation means in the context of organisations…

Sega VR

Sometimes, the world isn’t ready for your innovation.  You can find yourself in limbo or failing by being ahead of your time.

Consider Sega’s VR headset from 1993, the subject of retrospective articles long before a 16 year old Palmer Lucky became interested in VR and started down a path that would lead to public interest and mainstream VR headset products. 

Innovation in organisations

In an organisational environment, we will need some context for scope at the very least. 

Enter the Innovation Matrix, as described by Greg Satell.

In this model we have 4 classes of innovation, which work well in terms of considering organisational goals.  Academia tends to spend a lot of time on basic research, where goals and necessary knowledge are ill defined, and commercial value can be almost exclusively understood as ‘potential’. 

Established businesses typically find it easier to work with sustaining innovation, and as described so clearly by Clayton Christensen are usually vulnerable to disruptive innovation which can turn infrastructure, expertise and specialisation into burdens rather than advantages. 

Disruptive is a natural domain for startups, often arising from new applications of basic research.  Finally, breakthrough innovation is where we see the mavericks, the inventors, and practices like open innovation.

Innovation matrix

There are no rules to say a commercial business can’t engage in basic research, far from it, but doing so would ethically need full understanding and agreement from whoever has a financial stake in the business profitability, whether that be shareholders, private owners/partners, investors, etc.  Similarly with the other quadrants of the matrix, operating in one that is not a natural fit for your organisation requires knowledge, understanding, the ability to predict impact and manage adaptive change and most importantly, the will to constructively address with the contradictions and challenges that true innovation will bring to your business practices.

That offers us a model to understand and discuss the goal for innovation in an organisations, but after that, how can we relate to this when innovating? 

Categorising innovations at a more practical level can offer us a bridge from the organisational context or goal for innovation, to the act of innovating

Considering your innovations in terms of your configuration (of your organisation and resources), your offerings (your products / services), or the experience (that you offer customers in dealing with you and your products / services) allows us to identify as a business or individual where we feel there is opportunity and appetite to innovate.  One book, ‘Ten Types of Innovation’, delivers a framework model with detail that is backed by research on thousands of successful innovations. 

Ten Types of Innovation

A framework that enables us to identify which parts of our business we are prepared to change is an immensely powerful tool; both for managing innovation as a business competence and for managing specific innovation opportunities in a way that offers the greatest chance of success.

The nature, categories, and purposes for innovation in your environment will depend on what you want (or need) them to be, regardless of whether you are an individual innovator, a startup enterprise, the CEO of a hundred year old enterprise, or one of the many public or civil servants across the globe. 

The value offered in different ways by innovation, and the costs you will incur to pursue these in different ways are myriad.  Your answer will depend on complex interactions between your business strategy, your culture, purpose, goals, and values, your brand and market position, your operating model, your appetite for change, and more.

Innovation is a complex field, but hopefully after reading this, the next time someone talks of innovation you can start a dialogue to truly explore what that means. 

What to know more?  Need help establishing what innovation is or even should be for your organisation?

Visit www.horizensolutions.co.uk or email info@horizensolutions.co.uk